the green why
the green why · a voice of the drama

The History of Music

Music is the voice of the drama: where the word falls silent, sound gives us weeping, terror, hope, and resurrection. From temple psalms without notation to Requiems and the 'Resurrection' Symphony, the history of music passes through one and the same law: idol, collapse, captivity, refounding.

A discipline as the voice of one law · the arc

Every age reads in four beats: the living is made an idol → the idol collapses → captivity → return (a remelting, not a restoration). Below — how music lived through this law, age after age.

1

The First Kingdoms: Sound at the Altar

~3000–500 BC
Music sounded at the altar — why has none of it reached us?
IDOL: music as servant to the cult of king and gods, a voice at the altar.
"The Queen's Lyre" from the necropolis of Ur (c. 2500 BC), the British Museum — the temple-and-palace music of the first kingdoms
"The Queen's Lyre" from the necropolis of Ur (c. 2500 BC), the British Museum — the temple-and-palace music of the first kingdoms

No sounding music survives from this age — notation scarcely existed, and only images of instruments, texts, and indirect testimonies have come down to us. We know that music was inseparable from temple and power: the harps and lyres of Ur, the trumpets and cymbals of the Temple of Jerusalem, the Levite singers. The Psalms of David carry rubrics for performance ('on stringed instruments,' 'to the choirmaster'), but the melodies themselves have not survived. The Hurrian hymn from Ugarit (c. 14th century BC) is the oldest known notated melody, but its reading is disputed. It is more honest to say: here music sounded before the idol — and its voice has not reached us.

  • Hurrian Hymn No. 6 (Ugarit)hymn to the goddess Nikkal c. 14th century BCthe oldest partially notated melody; the reconstruction is disputed
  • The Psalms of Davidthe Psalter texts — 1st millennium BCperformance rubrics survive, but the melodies do not
  • The Temple Music of Jerusalemthe singing of the Levites, trumpets, cymbals era of the First Templeknown through descriptions, not through its sound
2

Antiquity: Number as the Idol of Harmony

~500 BC – AD 200
Can a single number hold the whole harmony of the world?
IDOL: harmony reduced to number and reason, music as the order of the cosmos.
The Seikilos epitaph (1st–2nd cent. AD) — the oldest completely surviving work with ancient notation
The Seikilos epitaph (1st–2nd cent. AD) — the oldest completely surviving work with ancient notation

The Greeks were the first to conceive of music as a science of number: to Pythagoras is ascribed the discovery of the numerical ratios of the consonances (octave, fifth, fourth), and music took its place alongside arithmetic and geometry. There arose a theory of the modes and the doctrine of ethos — the influence of music upon the soul. But sounding monuments are almost entirely lacking: only a handful of fragments survive, the most complete of them the Seikilos epitaph (1st–2nd century AD), a short drinking song with full notation. The Delphic Hymns to Apollo (c. 128 BC) have come down to us partly, carved in stone. The idol here is the belief that the world is upheld by a perfect numerical harmony.

  • Pythagoras (tradition)the doctrine of the numerical ratios of the consonances 6th century BCthe attribution is legendary, but it took root in theory
  • The Delphic Hymns to Apollotwo hymns carved at Delphi c. 128 BCsurvive in part, with notation
  • The Seikilos Epitapha drinking song on a gravestone 1st–2nd century ADthe oldest musical work to survive complete
3

The Collapse of Antiquity and the Christian Refounding

~200–600
The pagan world has collapsed — where did sound find a new foundation?
COLLAPSE and CAPTIVITY: the pagan world falls — and the voice of prayer is born.
Mosaic of the choir of the Basilica of Sant'Ambrogio, Milan — at the sources of Latin liturgical chant
Mosaic of the choir of the Basilica of Sant'Ambrogio, Milan — at the sources of Latin liturgical chant

With the fall of the ancient order, music loses its former foundation and is recast within the Church: liturgical chant is born — not for delight, but for prayer. No scores survive from this age: the singing was oral, and notation would appear only later. From the testimonies we know of antiphonal singing (choirs answering one another), which tradition associates with St Ambrose of Milan. In his Confessions, St Augustine describes how the singing at Milan shook him to tears — an early witness to the power of the Church's voice. This is captivity and the beginning of the refounding: music departs from the theatre and the circus into the temple.

  • Ambrose of Milanthe tradition of antiphonal singing and hymns 4th centurythe attribution is largely traditional; no scores survive
  • Augustine, Confessionsa testimony to the power of Church singing c. 397–400a text, not music; it describes how the singing moved him to tears
  • Early liturgical chantpsalmody, an oral tradition 3rd–6th centuriestransmitted by ear, without notation
4

The Medieval Cathedral: One Voice and the Birth of Polyphony

~600–1350
A single voice reaches toward heaven — when will it begin to branch?
RETURN and growth: one melody toward heaven, then the first voices of polyphony.
"Kyrie" in square neumatic notation (Liber Usualis) — the single voice of Gregorian chant before the birth of polyphony
"Kyrie" in square neumatic notation (Liber Usualis) — the single voice of Gregorian chant before the birth of polyphony

Gregorian chant takes shape — a monophonic liturgical singing that became the musical corpus of the West; tradition links its formation to the name of Pope Gregory I, though its notation crystallized later. From the 9th–11th centuries notation appears — and for the first time music becomes something that can be written down. At Notre-Dame Cathedral, Léonin and Pérotin create early polyphony (the organum), and the voice begins to branch. Hildegard of Bingen composes visionary monodies, and in the 14th century Guillaume de Machaut creates the 'Messe de Nostre Dame' — the first complete authored Mass by a single composer. The voice of the cathedral rises upward, toward heaven, and learns to sound in many layers.

  • Gregorian chantthe corpus of liturgical monophony takes shape 7th–10th centuriesthe name of Pope Gregory I is tradition; the notation took shape later
  • Pérotin (Pérotin the Great)the organa 'Viderunt omnes' and 'Sederunt principes' c. 1200the Notre-Dame school, early polyphony
  • Hildegard of Bingen'Ordo Virtutum', liturgical chants 12th centurymonodies, with her own sacred texts and melodies
  • Guillaume de Machaut'Messe de Nostre Dame' c. 1360one of the first complete authored Masses
5

The Renaissance and the Scientific Revolution: Pure Polyphony and the Birth of Opera

~1350–1700
Within perfect polyphony a turn is ripening — where does sound go to weep?
The IDOL of human harmony, then a breakthrough to drama and the personal voice.
Title page of Monteverdi's "Orfeo," Venice, 1609 — the birth of opera
Title page of Monteverdi's "Orfeo," Venice, 1609 — the birth of opera

Polyphony reaches the summit of perfection: Palestrina writes transparent Masses (among them the 'Missa Papae Marcelli'), and Josquin des Prez and Orlando di Lasso bring the interweaving of voices to its ideal. Yet within this perfection a turn toward the human being ripens: around 1600, in Florence, opera is born, and in his 'Orfeo' (1607) Monteverdi makes music the bearer of living drama and passion. His 'Lament of Ariadna' and his 'Vespers of the Blessed Virgin' (1610) join the old piety to the new expressiveness. Thus begins the Baroque — an age in which sound learns to weep and to rejoice in a human way.

  • Josquin des PrezMasses and motets c. 1450/55–1521the summit of Franco-Flemish polyphony
  • Giovanni Pierluigi da Palestrina'Missa Papae Marcelli' publ. 1567the model of clear ecclesiastical polyphony
  • Claudio Monteverdithe opera 'L'Orfeo' 1607the birth of opera as musical drama
  • Claudio Monteverdi'Vespro della Beata Vergine' (Vespers) 1610a bridge between polyphony and the new style
6

The Enlightenment and the Revolutions: the Passion, the Messiah, and the Requiem

~1700–1815
Can music lead us from Golgotha to the "Hallelujah"?
COLLAPSE and CAPTIVITY, mourned by music: the Passion of Christ, death and hope.
J. S. Bach, portrait by E. G. Haussmann (1748) — the summit of the age of the Passions
J. S. Bach, portrait by E. G. Haussmann (1748) — the summit of the age of the Passions

The Baroque and Classicism give music the highest capacity to bear the drama of salvation. Bach writes the 'St Matthew Passion' (1727) — a vast lament over Golgotha — and the Mass in B minor; Handel in 'Messiah' (1742) leads from prophecy through death to the 'Hallelujah' of the Resurrection. Haydn in the oratorio 'The Creation' (1798) sings of the light born out of chaos. Mozart dies over his unfinished 'Requiem' (1791), while Beethoven, in his Ninth Symphony (1824) and his 'Missa solemnis', leads music toward a universal, all-human brotherhood. It is the age of revolutions — and music holds within itself both the collapse and the hope.

  • Johann Sebastian Bach'St Matthew Passion', BWV 244 1727the summit of musical lament over the Passion
  • George Frideric Handelthe oratorio 'Messiah' 1742the path from prophecy to the 'Hallelujah' of the Resurrection
  • Joseph Haydnthe oratorio 'The Creation' 1798light out of chaos
  • Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart'Requiem' (unfinished) 1791completed by his pupils, chiefly Süssmayr
  • Ludwig van BeethovenSymphony No. 9 1824the 'Ode to Joy' — a hymn to brotherhood
7

The 19th Century: Romanticism, Requiems, and 'Resurrection'

~1815–1914
An age of the hero and of death — why does it sing of the Resurrection?
The IDOL of the hero and the nation, yet also great Requiems and the tidings of Resurrection.
Gustav Mahler, 1909 — whose "Resurrection" Symphony carried the Romantic search for the eternal to its limit
Gustav Mahler, 1909 — whose "Resurrection" Symphony carried the Romantic search for the eternal to its limit

Romanticism makes an idol of the artist's personality, of passion, and of the nation: Wagner builds his myth in 'The Ring of the Nibelung', and the symphony swells to a cosmic breadth. But the age of death also gives birth to great funeral Masses: Verdi writes his 'Requiem' (1874) with its shattering 'Dies irae', and Brahms his 'German Requiem' (1868) on words of consolation for the living. The culmination is Mahler: his Symphony No. 2, 'Resurrection' (1894), passes through death, judgment, and chaos to the choral 'I shall rise again!'. Here the law of history sounds directly: collapse and refounding into hope.

  • Johannes Brahms'A German Requiem' 1868a requiem of consolation for the living, on German biblical texts
  • Giuseppe Verdi'Requiem' 1874the dramatic 'Dies irae'
  • Richard Wagner'The Ring of the Nibelung' (the tetralogy) complete 1876myth and leitmotif as a new musical language
  • Gustav MahlerSymphony No. 2, 'Resurrection' 1894through death and judgment — to a choral resurrection
8

The 20th Century: the Rupture, the Horror of War, and a Quiet Return

~1914–1991
Harmony fell apart in the horror of wars — whence came the quiet light?
COLLAPSE and CAPTIVITY: the disintegration of the language, the horror of wars and dictatorships — and the search for light.
Igor Stravinsky — whose "The Rite of Spring" detonated the age of rupture and wars
Igor Stravinsky — whose "The Rite of Spring" detonated the age of rupture and wars

Music undergoes the ruin of its former harmony: Stravinsky, in 'The Rite of Spring' (1913), detonates rhythm; Schoenberg departs into atonality and dodecaphony, severing the bond with the mode. The age of totalitarianism and war cries out in sound: Shostakovich, in his Seventh, 'Leningrad', Symphony (1942), bears witness to the siege; Britten, in his 'War Requiem' (1962), interweaves the Mass for the dead with the verses of the fallen poet Owen. Out of the captivity a quiet light is born: Arvo Pärt creates the prayerful 'tintinnabuli' style ('Cantus in Memory of Britten', 1977; 'Tabula rasa', 1977). Horror and prayer — the two voices of the century.

  • Igor Stravinsky'The Rite of Spring' 1913the rhythmic breaking of the old language
  • Arnold Schoenbergthe method of composition with twelve tones (dodecaphony) formulated c. 1921–1923the break with tonality
  • Dmitri ShostakovichSymphony No. 7, 'Leningrad' 1942a witness to the war and the siege
    ♪ recording under copyright — available on streaming services
  • Benjamin Britten'War Requiem' 1962the Mass plus the anti-war verse of Wilfred Owen
    ♪ recording under copyright — available on streaming services
  • Arvo Pärt'Tabula rasa', 'Cantus in Memory of Benjamin Britten' 1977a prayerful minimalism, 'tintinnabuli'
    ♪ recording under copyright — available on streaming services
9

After the Ideologies: the Return of Silence and Faith

1991–
The idols have fallen — why are we drawn again to silence and prayer?
RETURN: through the disintegration of the ideologies — a longing for prayer, for silence, for the root.
Arvo Pärt — whose "tintinnabuli" marks the return of silence and faith after the age of ideologies
Arvo Pärt — whose "tintinnabuli" marks the return of silence and faith after the age of ideologies

After the collapse of the great ideologies, music seeks not a new idol but a return to the source — to silence, to prayer, to simplicity. The 'sacred minimalism' of Pärt, Górecki, and Tavener sounds ever louder in the world: Górecki's Symphony No. 3, of 'Sorrowful Songs' (composed 1976), becomes a worldwide hit precisely in the 1990s. John Tavener writes the Orthodox-inspired 'Song for Athene' (1993) and 'The Protecting Veil'. Against the endless stream of pop and electronic music, this quiet voice of faith is a sign of the refounding: weariness with noise turns into a longing for the eternal.

  • Henryk GóreckiSymphony No. 3, 'Symphony of Sorrowful Songs' written 1976, worldwide success in the 1990ssorrow and prayer that became popular
    ♪ recording under copyright — available on streaming services
  • John Tavener'Song for Athene' 1993Orthodox-inspired funeral music
    ♪ recording under copyright — available on streaming services
  • Arvo Pärtthe continuation of 'tintinnabuli' (e.g. 'Da pacem Domine', 2004) 1990s–2000sone of the most-performed living composers
    ♪ recording under copyright — available on streaming services
This is one of four voices-doors. The same law, in other mouths:

The spine of it all — the arc.